Holiday Gift Guide »

Touchscreens: who’s got it right and wrong…?

By: , IntoMobile
Friday, November 14th, 2008 at 12:37 PM
The touchscreen on the iPhone 3G is VERY good...

These days, seemingly not an hour goes by before another touchscreen device is announced (okay, it might not be hourly, but it does seem to happen quite often!). Yes, touchscreen has become de rigeur this year, and if you don’t have some mechanism to rub your equipment, then you just ain’t part of the cool crowd :-)

Touch has been implemented in a plethora of ways since it appeared in the Ericsson Communicator device, YEARS ago – there were probably limited examples before this, but if there were, my brain cells long since disposed of them!

But in fact Touch was brought to the fore in recent years by the advent not of Touchscreen-only devices, but actually by the mass-market inception (in Mobile devices) of the original LG Chocolate. That had some kind of heat-sensitive softkeys, and Samsung quickly followed suit. (Much) later, Sony Ericsson even put some of the same kind of keys on their “ok-ish” K850i.

But of course, Apple were waiting in the wings, having spent a very long time getting touch working perfectly on the four generations of iPod they had released – and when they pulled the trigger on the iPhone, people couldn’t believe how accurate and sensitive the new touch experience was, compared to the likes of the WinMO Pocket-PC derivatives, and SE UIQ devices.

Of course, Apple have gone on to roaring success by twinning accurate touch with friendly-UI – a task I don’t believe any other touchscreen device vendor has yet achieved (by the way that’s a call to any and all touchscreen device manufacturers to send me your ‘excellent’ touch devices if you think you have one that cuts it). I played with the HTC Touch Pro recently, and was saddened by the need to have to get out the Stylus for example – I thought we had done away with those now!

Apple don’t have the market to themselves for Touch devices though – Samsung and LG are pushing hard in this space, and Nokia is ready to enter – and these guys are bringing something else to the table – Haptic (vibrative) feedback. The idea is that you can replicate the feel of a physical key/button to some extent by vibrating the screen when it is touched. Basic implementations vibrate the whole screen; advanced implementations just the area where your finger made contact.

Quite what the next chapter of touch holds, no-one quite knows – but you can bet there are at least five BIG manufacturers working like crazy on getting the next device out there. I leave you with one final thought which is that it’s generally assumed it is your finger(s) doing the touching on the screen – but you wonder if people are experimenting with other bodyparts…… ;-)

What is your favourite touch-enabled device? Let us know in the comments…

SPONSORED MESSAGE
Get free domestic and international calls and texts to anyone with the Vonage Mobile app available as an iPhone calling app or Android calling app.

About The Author

Ben Robinson

Ben is a 10+ year veteran of the Mobile industry – starting his career when SMS was a still a relatively new concept for most people (!), he has now consulted on everything from bleeding-edge Mobile content, to the next-gen accessories you might view it on. As a result he has a broad and deep knowledge in numerous areas of Mobile – from network operators to device vendors, to infrastructure and middleware vendors (not to mention content delivery) – and has worked for companies in all of these areas! He is based in the UK, a hotbed of activity for mobile, and recently became a father for the second time – as oppose to in his younger years when he was happy spend time tweaking all manner of mobile devices to 'nth' degree, he now looks for services and hardware that provide the most efficient, compact, and reliable improvements to his already manic life! It’s his opinion that Mobile solutions should be there to help to make your life better – if a particular solution (be it service or device) isn’t doing this, he believes you need to ask the very important question of why you continue to use it... His focus at IntoMobile is mainly on Mobile content, services, and infrastructure, particularly as regards the UK market – and with the occasional look at devices. Additionally, using his extensive experience in the industry, he will provide commentary on the industry at large, with regular (and hopefully thought-provoking) articles.

  • Tom

    My next touchphone be the Nokia 5800 Xpressmusic “Tube”
    for shoore , yes the touch are nice in iphone but sad it lack all other things you need , like MMS , Copy/Paste Better Camera , shoot Video ,use like webcam etc.

    But yes there be real good stuff upcoming soon !
    The Tube is just the beginning of a new level.

  • 4DThinker

    Since the iPhone/Touch came out from Apple I’ve been looking hard for something better and truly expected to see something by now. There are products with better features (Samsung P2 with great Bluetooth capabilities, Samsung Instinct with a longer feature list than the iPhone, etc.) but none so far that makes the touchscreen experience so fluid. What everyone fails to realize is that Apple didn’t come up with the hardware and software of the iPhone overnight. I suspect they’ve been playing with the concept since the Newton. Everyone else seems to be just starting out. Not really innovating. No deep research behind their efforts.

    I expect 2009 to bring out a few peers (to the iPhone). 2010 may show us some stunning advancement. Hopefully all the beginners will take note of their failures this year and learn from them.

    4D

  • Harry

    Nokia 5800 ftw. So much more features and the features are better than other touchscreen phones

  • nick

    I’m always surprised that no mentions the existence of Palm and Palm OS, basically the creators of the PDA. Yes Apple had its Newton (but I don’t remember who was first) but they dropped the Newton since it wasn’t competing with the Palms. So maybe Palm is ‘old’ these days, but they’ve been in the smartphone business long before the iPhone and always with a touch screen that didn’t require a stylus.