First impressions: CoPilot Live for iPhone
By Ben Robinson on Tuesday, August 25th, 2009 at 2:38 PM PST In Applications, Reviews
Those kind people at ALK Technologies have sorted me out with a copy of CoPilot Live for my iPhone, following my original post (here) on it’s release.
Interestingly, I just had a mount for the iPhone fitted to my car, so I was more than keen to give this App a go and see if it competes with standalone GPS modules that you attached to the windscreen. By my reckoning, a key thing about Sat Nav Apps (and much the same with standalone devices) is whether they thrash your battery, so I was relieved that my iPhone mount also doubles as a charging unit – leaving the worry of my battery behind for the moment. Anyway, more about the CoPilot App.
For this first impressions post, I decided I wanted a use-case that would mirror the situation of just getting the App, and then needing it suddenly. Fortunately that didn’t take very long, as we were off to visit friends who had moved house (and thus in a new location) at the weekend.
Having downloaded and installed the App (didn’t take too long), I popped the iPhone 3GS in to the car mount, flipped on the GPS (I usually have it turned off to conserve battery), and fired up the App.
Everything was blindingly simple. A little pop-up wizard gives you options of what you want to do, and I wanted to navigate via postcode. In the background the App was checking satellites, after I had given it permission to use my GPS location. I’d assume you might be able to triangulate your position using WiFi/3G if no GPS was available, but I didn’t test that.
Now, the App costs £25 in the UK, and that compares very favourably with the two other big contenders, Navigon and TomTom – they both come in around the £55-60 mark. I was wondering whether the lower cost would mean reduced performance or features – and with my first impressions review it was the performance I was doubly concerned about. I need not have worried – once I got past the keyboard for inputting the postcode (it’s not a QWERTY layout, which isn’t logical to me), then we were locked on and ready to go in a matter of seconds.
During the course of the 30 minute journey, the App was absolutely spot-on with it’s instructions, and the map was VERY clear indeed – way better than my standalone legacy Sat Nav. The vocal directions were good, and rather to the point: “take next turn” was common instead of “take the next turn” – which is merely me being picky about natural language support.
Overall though, the App was very responsive, accurate, and even the projected time of arrival was dynamically adjusted and ended up being very accurate indeed. So overall, an excellent result from a real use-case that many people might experience.
I’d heartily recommend this App based on basic usage, and I’d suspect the more advanced features will be good too – I’ll hopefully have some more real-world use cases to try them soon. In the meanwhile I wonder how the higher-priced solutions are going to compete and differentiate themselves, as CoPilot Live for the iPhone is very, very good indeed!
You can find CoPilot Live for the iPhone on the App Store, under the Navigation category.
Wow! this new app sounds great, I mean even better than GPS.. and the price is also quite reasonable, I feel Iphone users should give this a try once..Thanks for sharing your experiences.. Its really good
I’d go as far as to say that Co-Pilot is twice the application for half the price of its rivals, except for one aspect, widely experienced by the Co-Pilot owning iPhone community – it’s routing and ETAs are wildly unreliable/illogical. If you’re having success with it, could you publish the routing profile settings that you’re using? Against a Nav 6 TomTom PDA, it’s suggesting ETAs of approx twice the accurate timing of TomTom and can’t successfully route a journey from one end of the same road to the other! If this isn’t just poor settings by users, this is a major flaw that can’t be overcome by the great bells & whistles provided.
That is sooooo not true… I am wondering if you really live in Canada or US, the map data is terrible, I mean it! it is completely put of data. I dont know if the writer of this article take money from “CoPilot Live” or what, how can he recommend such a poor apple app to the reader.
Just checkout my extensive review. I had no route problems or like described above, I use it daily now and it’s chosen routes are the ones I would take too. I have the Europe edition for iPhone. However the NA edition we tested does not have the same ranking.
http://www.iphonetunes.net/index.php/apps/comments/iphonetunes_review_copilot_live_vs_tomtom/
Well I just bought this app and sooo really wanted to love it because of its price and it not being TOM TOM.
I was running it on a new Iphone 3GS and mounted in the windscreen of a Ford Mondeo.
I should have known that there would be problems on the outset of my first real journey – For the first 500 metres the Sat Nav was spinning like I was in a crashing helicopter – then as I drove up the A38 it kept telling me I was on the small B roads running alongside – It soon settled down and its perfomance was OK until I reached London.
Then it started getting really confused – at complex junctions the instructions came too late too follow and the scale of the mapping was too small to follow – if I missed the exit – which was happening a lot – it took too long to straighten itself out to be of any use –
Then on a small journey to Camden – it would instruct me to go left – then go right – and point straight ahead! you should try living with that in London traffic! Then it would freeze and and by the time it sorted itself out we where completely at a loss – my girlfreind thought it was joke! – I have asked for refund – its really not ready for anything but the simplest navigation scenario – and I imagine TOM TOM is no better – why that is I dont know – my 2 year Blackberry did a much better job -