Holiday Gift Guide »

Helsinki Nokia N900 Meetup: The Maemo guys have heart, but is that enough?

Categories: Linux, Nokia
By: , IntoMobile
Wednesday, October 21st, 2009 at 2:36 PM

I just came back from the first of six international Nokia N900 meetups. The Helsinki event took place in none other than the Nokia Flagship Store, a shop that I used to visit quite often during my usual daily strolls down main street, but have lately been ignoring due to Nokia’s present uninspiring portfolio of devices. I’m still on the fence as to whether or not it was a success, but I know that has something to do with the former financial analyst in me who would like to see some hard numbers. A success, by my definition, would be recuperating the costs of these events, with Nokia N900 purchases from the people in attendance. I’ll never know if this event, or the five similar events coming up are actually cost effective, but I did discover something just by showing up. Nokia employees working on Maemo have hearts.

There are four types of Nokia employees. You have the majority of employees, who do their job just so they can pay the bills. They’ve established a mind numbing routine and are indifferent about their role, but they know that working for Nokia allows them a gracious amount of time off, flexible working hours, and a healthy severance package should they become fired. Then you have the people who are actually into the mobile industry and really do care about where Nokia is heading, but unfortunately they’re in roles that have little to no impact towards the future device or service portfolio. There are a healthy number of these individuals, I used to be one of them. Next you have the people who actually work on the future devices and services Nokia will be releasing, the people who get their hands dirty, the people who use an IDE more than they use PowerPoint. These people care about what they’re doing, developers love solving problems and seeing a project rise from concept to product, but they may not exactly care about Nokia or the wireless industry as a whole. Finally you have the people who are in the right place, at the right time, and doing the right thing. These people may or may not have technical savvy, but are in a position to change things and are really excited about the things they’re working on, what their work will mean for Nokia, and the mobile telecommunications as a whole. Few of these sort of people exist, but I was fortunate enough to meet a few at tonight’s event.

Maemo employees, and I’m not going to name names since I don’t want to get people in trouble, know what they’re up against. They know the iPhone offers a fantastic consumer experience, but deep down they really do care that it is a locked down platform where developers play by Apple’s rules. They know Android is on the tip of everyone’s tongues, but they oppose the fact that Google worked to build something that is open on paper, but in reality is just Google saying “we know there is stuff out there in the open source community that does what we want to do, but we’re just going to write, from scratch, the bits and pieces we want to make so they can be exactly how we like them; to shut the community up we’ll just open source everything”. They know that the N900 will be what the technology media people will be talking about when it hits stores next month, but they’re humble and admit that internally their judgement day, when all Maemo employees receive self vindication, will be when the device after the N900 running Maemo 6 will be on store shelves.

The enthusiasm Maemo people have about open source software is astounding. They don’t want to build something from scratch, open source it, and call it a day. Instead Maemo people look at the best at what open source offers today and then takes from all those projects whatever it can to combine it into what you and I call Maemo. I never really understood that until tonight. To me “open source” has become such an overused phrase that I’ve associated it with filthy marketing talk. One Maemo employee whispered to me “notice how there are no marketing people here tonight?” and at that point I realized the whole concept of these events was not about pushing the Nokia N900, but pushing Maemo and the concept of open source to a greater audience.

I may not agree with open source people. They probably hate the fact that I use Windows 7, that I don’t give a shit as to whether my software is open or not, and that I constantly bring up the fact that going to an open source event is like waking up in a world where females never existed. That being said, open source people are free thinkers, and the people who talked to me today did not spew the well rehearsed Nokia corporate communications quotes, they actually started their sentences “well … personally I think …”; unheard of since Nokia marketing people are not allowed to have their own opinions when speaking to a public facing audience.

The Maemo guys have heart, and people with passion get far in life, but can this team execute on a mission to bring the best open source software device to market? I’ll just have to wait and see. I can’t offer anything else that that.

Just wait and see.

Oh and one more thing: congratulations to my mate Henrikki for winning a Nokia N900 tonight.

About The Author

Stefan Constantinescu

Stefan Constantinescu (@WhatTheBit on Twitter) has loved technology since as far back as he can remember. It started with computers, but in the past few years his passion has turned to mobile devices. As a mobile phone enthusiast who lives and breathes devices that connect to the internet, he knows he is not alone with this radical fascination of all things wireless. He is strongly opinionated and enjoys a good debate so leave comments in his posts and he’ll get back to you! Stefan began blogging as a hobby in the fall of 2006 and joined IntoMobile in the summer of 2007. Later he got a job at Nokia in March 2008, but as of June 2009 he has rejoined the IntoMobile team. He is currently based out of Helsinki, Finland.

  • Matti

    “I constantly bring up the fact that going to an open source event is like waking up in a world where females never existed.”

    So there is at least common factor between open and closed source software events, exluding the bimbo hired to handing out flyers at the latter.

  • manu

    lol
    (Your comment was a bit too short. Please go back and try again.)
    lol x2

  • Scofflaw Mike

    “They probably hate the fact that I use Windows 7, that I don’t give a shit as to whether my software is open or not…”

    I think that’s a bit strong. For example granted I’m no open source developer, I’m reading and writing this on PC. However my IBM Netfinity 5500 is humming loudly in rack next to me running Debian 5.0

    I all the open source dogma my mantra remains the same; Windows lets you do something with your computer. Linux is for when you want your computer to do something.

    Here’s hoping that Maemo can bridge the gap.

  • Peter

    Thanks for joining!

    In regards to your valid question on business case of these get-together events, I guess we all know the short term answer when we hand out food, merchandise, and some N900, but we don’t sell a single device. It’s an investment to consumer understanding and engagement with enthusiasts that provide valuable feedback.

    And yes, you happened to talk for a good time to our open source advocate and therefore you got a the little flavor of our open source angle. But open source is not a religion for us as such. We believe that open source is the best way for us not only to get contributions from b2b partners, commercial collaborators, but also from outstanding individuals. And this works only when you share your contributions from day 1 and you are transparent on what you are doing next.

    Wait a little, see the Nokia N900, and calculate the potential of Maemo, now and in the future.

  • Micky

    Great article Stefan. Enjoyed reading this, and you have touched on many aspects which come to no surprise to me, especially regarding the types of employees, the ones who have passion for what they do, and actually have a very strong interest in the mobile world, and/or Nokia as a brand.

  • matt

    Great article, I found it very insightful.

  • Henrikki

    Thanks Stefan..:)

    Nice article, alltough I would have liked to hear your impressions of the device itself too.

  • Stefan Constantinescu

    I’m reserving my thoughts on the N900 until I get to play with final software. I would not do the system justice if I just did a “first impression” type blog post.

  • afaq

    i too am quite sceptical of the so called “open sourced” communities and corporations who promote it. the power of maemo and the hardware of the n900 needs to be utilised properly.
    N97- though quite powerful lacks the imagination to make it a great device.

    Maemo is a chance for nokia to re-invent itself in the eyes of those who gave up a while ago. The N series worked quite well but it lacks the customer keeping power. If N900 falls in the same holes as the N97, I can only say sadly I will be turning away from Nokia to android “droid” and give google a chance.

  • Pat

    For a mass-market embedded commercial device, open or closed source is not as important as a completely open API. Even if you fix that bug in the N900s usb drivers, you’re not going to get John Q Public to rebuild his N900 kernel; you’re going to have to code your app to work-around the problem.

    IMO, N900 is not a device for consumers anyway – it’s for developers and early adopters. I agree the next version will be for consumers, when developers have created a commercial library and early adopters have helped Nokia finalize the UX.