Are 3D smartphones right for you? Maybe not yet …

The great 3D debate
The great 3D debate

This week at CTIA 2011 in Orlando we saw something that we really haven’t seen in smartphones before: glasses-free 3D displays. We knew they were coming, but it’s certainly something else to hold it in your hands and to see for yourself. The two showstoppers were most certainly the HTC EVO 3D for Sprint, and the LG Thrill 4G for AT&T. Both are capable of capturing and displaying three-dimensional photos and images that you can view on your phone, but that’s where our first problem comes up.

At a few parties in Orlando, I kept hearing the word “gimmick” when others would describe 3D smartphones. Indeed, it does seem like a gimmick because its usefulness is limited and your ability to share content is virtually non-existent. You can’t share 3D photos and videos on Twitter, Facebook or Flickr at the moment, but maybe that will change if this 3D thing really takes off.

3D phones have a long way to go. I spent a considerable amount of time with both the HTC EVO 3D and the LG Thrill 4G and neither one really wowed me. It’s neat to see the dual cameras on the back of the phones, which indicate the ability to record 3D photos and videos. It’s also pretty cool to see the content on the phone when you can actually see it–another problem with the technology right now.

The viewing angle is so limited that it’s hard to get it right when it’s in your hands. Sharing it with others standing around you makes it even more tricky. While waiting to get my hands on a device, the person before me would say, “Oh, this looks really cool! Check it out!” But no matter how hard they tried to angle it to make it viewable by me, it just never worked. Things have to be perfectly aligned and the phone needs to be in your own hands in order for the effect to work.

When it does work, however, it is really cool. It’s like there is a whole new world within your smartphone. The picture and video samples in the EVO 3D were just about perfect. Even without glasses, images and videos were crisp and colors were rich and vivid. But if you were nudged over and the smartphone moved a centimeter either way, you’d be hit with the blur effect.

Are 3D phones the future of multimedia on our smartphones? I wouldn’t bet against it, but right now the technology seems really limited and I can’t see users taking to it because it’s really a one-person experience. We’re so accustomed with sharing the minutiae of our lives through Twitter, Facebook, Foursquare, Flickr and other social networks that it’d be disappointing to have to experience the cool 3D photos and images we took ourselves.

  • I am really glad I read this article! With this it has really helped me with my decision.

  • Anonymous

    Though this blog only we can identify this one right for us or not.. Thanks for this great article..
    Aluminium Kozijnen

  • Jeff2025

    Marc, you’re saying there’s no social network to share pictures or videos, but what about
    YouTube 3D ???

    • That’s what I was going to say… at MWC 2011 in Barcelona, LG and YouTube announced a partnership for 3D content on the Google videos site, and once the 3D content is online it can be shared via Twitter, Facebook, and whatever you use. Furthermore both HTC and LG have HDMI and DLNA, allowing to play the 3D content on 3D TV screens, obviously with glasses.

  • Radiohawk3

    i think its the steve jobs love affair you’re having… dont worry someday you’ll escape from the evil cult and rejoin the rest of the world

  • Very biased article

Back to top ▴