Holiday Gift Guide »

Nexus One has less available memory than Droid?

By: , IntoMobile
Thursday, March 4th, 2010 at 8:20 PM

An interesting story over at AndroidForums has surfaced. It looks like out of all that 512MBs on the spec sheet of the Nexus One, only 196MBs are available to the user. Fixes have been promised, but nothing more.

Over at the XDA forums, someone got hold of Romaine Guy in an IRC channel, an Android developer that works for Google, and posted their conversation. It seems like the issue with the Nexus One is connected to the kernel, and an upcoming update will be solving this issue. Note: the conversation below took place in January, and the more recent update for the Nexus One was in February, although the problem has still not been addressed.

“ How can the Droid have 256MB of RAM but 230+MB memfree, while the Nexus has 512MB RAM but only 218MB memfree?

<@romainguy_> there’s a limitation in the kernel

<@romainguy_> next update should give you 100 or 150 MB back

<coolbho3k> Very nice!!!”

For those who need brushing up on what a kernel is: “The kernel is the central component of most computer operating systems(ie; Android) It is a bridge between applications and the actual data processing done at the hardware level.”

Now there have been RAM hacks for the G1, and the MyTouch 3g, which add about 10Mbs of RAM taken from the GPU of the device, but adding 100-150 MBs of RAM doesn’t seem plausible. The devs over at XDA do some great things, but with a situation like this, it should be left for the people who get paid for it – Google developers themselves.

Even with the RAM missing, I can’t complain on the speed of my Nexus One, this thing flies! It is interesting, and somewhat funny how the Nexus One may have more RAM than the Motorola Droid, but the Droid actually has more RAM available to it. Surprise, sucka!

Hopefully Google gets this one right, and soon. The Nexus One has enough issues already.

About The Author

Blake Stimac

Blake was born in Beaumont, Texas, about 100 miles away from Houston. Even as a youngster, technology came to him very naturally, tinkering with anything he could. His passion of technology grew with mobile phones when he dreamed that the capabilities of phones would eventually make one's life much easier. Since then it's been his mission to advocate the push of mobile technology to anyone who will listen.

  • SnowMan

    From the article above “the more recent update for the Nexus One was in February, although the problem has still not been addressed” neither have any of the other problems! In fact the update introduced the new (at least to the Nexus One) problem of pinch-zoom related touchscreen errors.

  • coolbho3k

    This article takes the quote (my quote!) out of context and is seriously FUD.

    The extra memory is stable, has been added in kernel 2.6.32, and is already in pretty much all of the custom ROMs, it’s just not officially OTA’d by Google yet. At the time of the latest OTA (the infamous update that added multitouch), Google hadn’t backported the changes to 2.6.29, and 2.6.32 wasn’t stable yet. It is not a “hack” and doesn’t take away memory from the GPU or baseband.

    • Blake Stimac

      I just pasted your conversation that the quote (your quote!) came from.

      And I was referring to the previous ramhacks that have been implemented into other android devices, that renders 3d gameplay pretty useless if you use it.