Holiday Gift Guide »

Must read whitepaper about LTE: In support of VoLGA over CSFB and IMS

Categories: Infrastructure
By: , IntoMobile
Thursday, August 27th, 2009 at 3:23 AM

Get a spoon ready, because I’m about to serve you a hot bowl of abbreviated industry jargon. We all want better mobile phone service. Doesn’t matter if you’re from America, Britain, Europe or Asia, you want to have signal everywhere you go and you want to be able to browse the web without having to wait 60 second for a site to come up. Today, over 80% of mobile handsets in use are powered by the GSM (Global System for Mobile (Communications)) standard. GSM networks are called 2G networks because they’re the digital evolution of the old analog system. A while back, at the turn of the century, UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunications System) was rolled out enhance GSM by giving people better access to the internet, along with adding the ability to do both voice and data at the same time. UMTS is known as 3G all over the world. More recently, HSPA (High Speed Packet Access) hit the scene, and that too is yet another evolution of the GSM standard, and it has enabled faster access to the internet both in terms of speed of transmission and latency. The world calls it 3.5G, while America still calls it 3G. In the next couple of years a new standard is coming to town called LTE (Long Term Evolution) and there is no question about it, this is definitely a 4G network technology.

LTE is radically different from previous technology since it is all IP based. Current networks are still circuit switched. WTF does that mean? When I call you, a little box that the operator owns has to physically make a connection between you and I for our conversation to take place. The operator is literally making an electrical circuit where sparks fly, just so I can tell you about how shit faced I plan on being over the weekend. With LTE, everything switches to IP, and while all that bandwidth is nice, there are no standards setup yet for voice and SMS.

I keep on telling people this, and they don’t get it, so let me repeat myself: LTE does not support voice and SMS. There are no industry agreed upon standards for voice and SMS over LTE.

Several proposals have been brought up to bring voice and SMS to LTE:

  • Circuit Switched Fallback (CSFB): When you get a call, or a text, your mobile phone would switch the connection to a 3G or even 2G network. This increases the amount of time it takes to reach someone after you hit that little green button, not to mention screws up your high speed tentacle rape pornography download.
  • Your connection does not degrade when receiving/sending a text.

  • IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS): A ridiculously complex system that even the experts have trouble describing to me. How am I supposed to tell you about it when even I don’t know how it works? More importantly, how are operators going to roll it out when even the people I know, who work for infrastructure companies, can’t explain how it works.
  • Voice over LTE via GAN (VoLGA): No modifications are required on the network. None. A simple gateway is used to connect calls and texts directly to the mobile switching centers. It’s all IP based, so there is no need to degrade your connection to 3G, EDGE, or GPRS.

Martin Sauter, my main man when it comes to breaking down mobile telecommunications infrastructure into digestibale pieces of easy to understand content, has written a white paper arguing why VoLGA is what the industry should use. I’ve given it a read, and I think you should too if you’re the type of person who is actually interested in understanding how mobile networks work.

It’s only 13 pages, the last 3 being a glossary: PDF document

Here is hoping operators make the right choice. I want my fast downloads, but at the same time I want to keep on texting my mates.

About The Author

Stefan Constantinescu

Stefan Constantinescu (@WhatTheBit on Twitter) has loved technology since as far back as he can remember. It started with computers, but in the past few years his passion has turned to mobile devices. As a mobile phone enthusiast who lives and breathes devices that connect to the internet, he knows he is not alone with this radical fascination of all things wireless. He is strongly opinionated and enjoys a good debate so leave comments in his posts and he’ll get back to you! Stefan began blogging as a hobby in the fall of 2006 and joined IntoMobile in the summer of 2007. Later he got a job at Nokia in March 2008, but as of June 2009 he has rejoined the IntoMobile team. He is currently based out of Helsinki, Finland.

  • Ulf Nilsson

    There is no fallback to legacy systems when receiving an SMS in CSFB. You’re comments are fine but get the facts straight before going on a bashing spree.

  • Stefan Constantinescu

    Need to look into that. Pinging Martin.

    EDIT: He just got back to me:

    “Fact is that for SMS over LTE, the CSFB feature is required. For SMS messages, however, no fallback is required, it is done over the LTE signaling part of the CSFB feature that can also indicate an incoming call (afer which the fallback would happen). So SMS delivery over LTE is part of the CSFB feature although it does not fall back for it.”

  • Terence Eden

    Interestingly, 3G video calls use a mixture of IP & CS. The voice part is circuit switched so if bandwidth becomes limited (or you drop to 2G) the call can continue. It’s also why voice & video are sometimes out of sync.

    I wonder how LTE will tie in with BT’s 21CN – that’s also an all-IP network.

  • Luke Thomas

    I agree with Ulf and Stefan with regard to the SMS delivery over CSFB….It is interesting that you did not cover the Fast Track solution (which is part of the standard 3GPP Rel 8) and resolves all the issues of CSFB. Apart from T-Mobile I do not see any traction for VoLGA and in fact I do not think it will be a ratified standard at the end of the day…Time will tell :) )